fr en es pt
Astronomy
Asteroids and Comets Black Holes Children Chemical Elements Constellations Earth Eclipses Environment Equations Evolution Exoplanets Galaxies Light Matter Moons Nebulas Planets and Dwarf Planets Probes and Telescopes Scientists Stars Sun Universe Volcanoes Zodiac New Articles Shorts Archives Glossary
RSS astronoo
Follow me on X
Follow me on Bluesky
Follow me on Pinterest
English
Français
Español
Português
 


Last updated July 29, 2025

The Origins of Mass: Between Inertia and Gravitation

Atlas LHC: Origin of the mass of particles

What is mass?

Mass is one of the most fundamental properties of matter. It determines a body's resistance to acceleration (inertial mass) and the gravitational force it exerts or undergoes (gravitational mass). Long considered intrinsic, mass is now understood as an emergent phenomenon within the framework of the Standard Model of particle physics.

Difference between inertial mass and gravitational mass

Inertial mass quantifies an object's resistance to any change in its state of motion. It appears in Newton's second law: \( \vec{F} = m_i \cdot \vec{a} \). The greater the inertial mass, the more force is needed to produce the same acceleration.

Gravitational mass determines the intensity of the gravitational force an object undergoes or exerts. In Newton's law, it appears as: \( F = G \cdot \dfrac{m_g M}{r^2} \), with \( m_g \) being the gravitational mass.

Fundamental fact: in all experiments, these two masses are numerically equivalent. This experimental observation, that a heavy or light object falls with the same acceleration in a vacuum, forms the basis of Einstein's equivalence principle. It is central to general relativity.

However, this equivalence is a postulate and not a theoretical necessity. Any difference, however slight, between \( m_i \) and \( m_g \) could reveal new physics. Missions like MICROSCOPE have tested this principle to 1 part in \( 10^{15} \), with no detected deviation to date.

Comparison between inertial mass and gravitational mass
Type of massDefinitionAssociated formulaExperimental measurement
Inertial mass (\( m_i \))Resistance to acceleration (dynamic)\[ \vec{F} = m_i \cdot \vec{a} \]Via applied forces (pushing, pulling)
Gravitational mass (\( m_g \))Interaction with the gravitational field\[ F = G \cdot \dfrac{m_g M}{r^2} \]Via weight or free fall
Equivalence principle\( m_i = m_g \)Identical acceleration in free fallVerified with extreme precision

References:
• Galileo G., Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems, 1632.
• Einstein A., The Foundation of the General Theory of Relativity, 1916.
• Touboul P. et al., MICROSCOPE Mission: First Results of a Space Test of the Equivalence Principle, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 231101 (2017).
• Will C.M., The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment, Living Rev. Relativity 17, 4 (2014).

The vacuum is not empty: The Higgs field

In the Standard Model, the vacuum is not empty: it is filled with a scalar field called the Higgs field. During the spontaneous breaking of electroweak symmetry, this field acquires a non-zero value throughout space. Particles interact with this field, and this interaction gives them a mass proportional to their coupling with the field. The Higgs boson, discovered in 2012, is the quantum excitation of this field.

Why protons and neutrons are massive

Quarks (the constituent elements of protons and neutrons) have a very small mass from the Higgs field, but most of the nucleon's mass (more than 98%) comes from the binding energy of quarks via the strong interaction (quantum chromodynamics). This phenomenon is a striking example of the mass-energy equivalence: \(E=mc^2\).

Origin of mass in fundamental entities
ObjectMass (MeV/$c^2$)Main originPart from the Higgs field
Electron0.511Higgs field100%
Up quark2.2Higgs field100%
Proton938QCD binding energy<2%
Neutron939QCD binding energy<2%

References:
• Higgs P., Broken Symmetries and the Masses of Gauge Bosons, Phys. Rev. Lett. 13, 508 (1964).
• Aad G. et al., Observation of a New Particle in the Search for the Standard Model Higgs Boson, Phys. Lett. B 716, 1–29 (2012).
• Peskin M.E. & Schroeder D.V., An Introduction to Quantum Field Theory, Addison-Wesley (1995).
• Particle Data Group, pdg.lbl.gov.

Mass in special relativity and general relativity

Special relativity (\(E=mc^2\)) establishes that mass and energy are equivalent.

General relativity (\( R_{\mu\nu} - \frac{1}{2} R\, g_{\mu\nu} = \frac{8\pi G}{c^4} T_{\mu\nu} \)) describes mass (and energy) as the source of spacetime curvature. Any form of energy, including that of a field or the vacuum, curves space and produces a gravitational effect.

The mystery persists

If the Higgs field today explains the origin of the mass of elementary particles via their interaction with the quantum vacuum, the profound nature of this field, its stability over time, and especially the precise value of its vacuum energy remain theoretical enigmas. Indeed, the vacuum energy predicted by relativistic quantum mechanics, and thus its equivalent gravitational mass, should generate a colossal curvature of spacetime, incompatible with the moderate expansion observed in the universe. This inconsistency constitutes the famous cosmological constant problem, related to the observed value of \( \Lambda \) in Einstein's equations:

\[ R_{\mu\nu} - \frac{1}{2} R\, g_{\mu\nu} + \Lambda g_{\mu\nu} = \frac{8\pi G}{c^4} T_{\mu\nu} \]

This discrepancy of more than 120 orders of magnitude between the expected theoretical value and the measured value of the cosmological constant is undoubtedly the largest gap ever encountered between theory and observation in fundamental physics. It raises profound questions about the relationship between inertial mass, gravitational mass, and the very structure of the quantum vacuum.

Cosmological constant: a discrepancy of 120 orders of magnitude

The cosmological constant \( \Lambda \), initially introduced by Einstein in his equations of general relativity, corresponds to a vacuum energy density that influences the expansion of the Universe. It is related to an effective energy density by:

\[ \rho_{\Lambda}^{\mathrm{obs}} = \dfrac{\Lambda c^{2}}{8\pi G} \]

Cosmological observations, particularly those from the cosmic microwave background, indicate that this density is extremely low. However, quantum field theory, which considers the contributions of all vacuum fluctuations up to a high-energy cutoff (often the Planck scale), predicts an immense vacuum density.

The discrepancy between the theoretical prediction \( \rho_{\text{vide}}^{\mathrm{th}} \) and the measured value \( \rho_{\Lambda}^{\mathrm{obs}} \) is of the order of:

\[ \frac{\rho_{\text{vide}}^{\mathrm{th}}}{\rho_{\Lambda}^{\mathrm{obs}}} \sim 10^{120} \text{ to } 10^{123} \]

This discrepancy of more than 120 orders of magnitude is unprecedented in the history of theoretical physics. It highlights a fundamental disagreement between general relativity (gravitation) and quantum mechanics (fields). The cosmological constant problem is one of the greatest mysteries of fundamental physics.

Orders of magnitude of vacuum energy
QuantityTypical valueUnitsOrigin
\( \rho_{\text{vide}}^{\mathrm{th}} \)\( \sim 10^{113} \)J m\(^{-3}\)Vacuum fluctuations at the Planck scale
\( \rho_{\Lambda}^{\mathrm{obs}} \)\( \sim 10^{-10} \)J m\(^{-3}\)Deduced from accelerated expansion
Ratio\( \sim 10^{123} \)DimensionlessTheory vs observation gap

In the natural units used in particle physics, this density is expressed in GeV\(^4\):

This profound disagreement indicates that something essential is missing in our understanding of the quantum vacuum or in the mechanism of gravitation on a large scale. This paradox is at the heart of research on a unified theory of quantum gravity.

References:
• Weinberg S., The Cosmological Constant Problem, Rev. Mod. Phys. 61, 1 (1989).
• Carroll S.M., The Cosmological Constant, Living Rev. Relativity 4, 1 (2001).
• Planck Collaboration, Cosmological parameters, A&A 641, A6 (2020).

Articles on the same theme

Heat and Temperature: Two Often Confused Thermal Notions Heat and Temperature: Two Often Confused Thermal Notions
Electroweak Force: The Unification of Electromagnetism and the Weak Interaction Electroweak Force: The Unification of Electromagnetism and the Weak Interaction
Special Relativity: The Beginning of a New Physics Special Relativity: The Beginning of a New Physics
The Higgs Boson: The Unification of Fundamental Forces The Higgs Boson: The Unification of Fundamental Forces
Quantum Entanglement: When Two Particles Become One! Quantum Entanglement: When Two Particles Become One!
The Pentaquark: A New Piece of the Cosmic Puzzle! The Pentaquark: A New Piece of the Cosmic Puzzle!
Why are Rare Gases rare? Why are Rare Gases rare?
Brownian Motion: A Link Between Two Worlds Brownian Motion: A Link Between Two Worlds
The 4 Articles of Albert Einstein from 1905 The 4 Articles of Albert Einstein from 1905
Why does nuclear fusion require so much energy? Why does nuclear fusion require so much energy?
Feynman diagrams and particle physics Feynman diagrams and particle physics
The nuclear instability barrier Stars cannot create elements heavier than iron because of the nuclear instability barrier
Alpha, Beta, and Gamma Radiation: Understanding Their Differences Alpha, Beta, and Gamma Radiation: Understanding Their Differences
Planck wall theory Planck wall theory
Is emptiness really empty? Is emptiness really empty?
The Large Hadron Collider The Large Hadron Collider
The hadron is not a fixed object The hadron is not a fixed object
Radioactivity, natural and artificial Radioactivity, natural and artificial
The World of Nanoparticles: An Invisible Revolution The World of Nanoparticles: An Invisible Revolution
Schrodinger's Cat Schrodinger's Cat
Before the big bang the multiverse Before the big bang the multiverse
Eternal inflation Eternal inflation
Gravitational waves Gravitational waves
What is a wave? What is a wave?
The fields of reality: what is a field? The fields of reality: what is a field?
Space in time Space in time
Quantum computers Quantum computers
Bose-Einstein condensate Bose-Einstein condensate
Equation of Newton's three laws Equation of Newton's three laws
Field concept in physics Field concept in physics
The electron, a kind of electrical point The electron, a kind of electrical point
Entropy and disorder Entropy and disorder
Light, all the light of the spectrum Light, all the light of the spectrum
The infernal journey of the photon The infernal journey of the photon
Mystery of the Big Bang, the problem of the horizon Mystery of the Big Bang, the problem of the horizon
Beta Radioactivity and Neutrino: A Story of Mass and Spin Beta Radioactivity and Neutrino: A Story of Mass and Spin
Spacetime: Space and Time United Spacetime: Space and Time United
Time Measurement: Scientific and Technological Challenge Time Measurement: Scientific and Technological Challenge
Physical and Cosmological Constants: Universal Numbers at the Origin of Everything Physical and Cosmological Constants: Universal Numbers at the Origin of Everything
Spectroscopy, an inexhaustible source of information Spectroscopy, an inexhaustible source of information
Abundance of chemical elements in the universe Abundance of chemical elements in the universe
The size of atoms The size of atoms
The magnetic order and magnetization The magnetic order and magnetization
The quark confinement The quark confinement
Superpositions of quantum states Superpositions of quantum states
Alpha decay (α) Alpha decay (α)
Electromagnetic induction equation Electromagnetic induction equation
Nuclear fusion, natural energy source Nuclear fusion, natural energy source
Does dark matter exist? Does dark matter exist?
From the Ancient Atom to the Modern Atom: An Exploration of Atomic Models From the Ancient Atom to the Modern Atom: An Exploration of Atomic Models
The Origins of Mass: Between Inertia and Gravitation The Origins of Mass: Between Inertia and Gravitation
From the Nucleus to Electricity: Anatomy of a Nuclear Power Plant From the Nucleus to Electricity: Anatomy of a Nuclear Power Plant
The Universe of X-rays The Universe of X-rays
How many photons to heat a coffee? How many photons to heat a coffee?
Seeing Atoms: An Exploration of Atomic Structure Seeing Atoms: An Exploration of Atomic Structure
Quantum tunneling of quantum mechanics Quantum tunneling of quantum mechanics
Entropy: What is Time? Entropy: What is Time?
The 12 Particles of Matter: Understanding the Universe at the Subatomic Scale The 12 Particles of Matter: Understanding the Universe at the Subatomic Scale
The Atomic Orbital: Image of the Atom The Atomic Orbital: Image of the Atom
Earth's radioactivity Earth's radioactivity
The vacuum has considerable energy The vacuum has considerable energy
The valley of stability of atomic nuclei The valley of stability of atomic nuclei
Antimatter and antiparticle Antimatter and antiparticle
What is an electric charge? What is an electric charge?
Our matter is not quantum! Our matter is not quantum!
Why use hydrogen in the fuel cell? Why use hydrogen in the fuel cell?
Newton and Einstein: Two Visions for the Same Mystery Newton and Einstein: Two Visions for the Same Mystery
E=mc2 explains the mass of the proton E=mc2 explains the mass of the proton
Einstein's Universe: Physical Foundations of the Theory of Relativistic Gravitation Einstein's Universe: Physical Foundations of the Theory of Relativistic Gravitation
1905, The Silent Revolution: When Einstein Rewrote the Laws of Nature 1905, The Silent Revolution: When Einstein Rewrote the Laws of Nature
What does the equation E=mc2 really mean? What does the equation E=mc2 really mean?
Between Waves and Particles: The Mystery of DualityBetween Waves and Particles: The Mystery of Duality
The Supercritical State of Water: Between Liquid and Gas, a Fourth Phase? The Supercritical State of Water: Between Liquid and Gas, a Fourth Phase?
Quantum Mechanics and Spirituality: Another Way to See the World Quantum Mechanics and Spirituality: Another Way to See the World

1997 © Astronoo.com − Astronomy, Astrophysics, Evolution and Ecology.
"The data available on this site may be used provided that the source is duly acknowledged."
How Google uses data
Legal mentions
English Sitemap − Full Sitemap
Contact the author