Astronomy
Asteroids and Comets Black Holes Children Chemical Elements Constellations Earth Eclipses Environment Equations Evolution Exoplanets Galaxies Light Matter Moons Nebulas Planets Dwarf Planets Probes and Telescopes Scientists Stars Sun Universe Volcanoes Zodiac New Articles Glossary
RSS astronoo
Follow me on X
Follow me on Bluesky
Follow me on Pinterest
English
Français
Español
Português
日本語
Deutsch
 
Last update: August 29, 2025

Lagrange Points: The Illusion of Stable Gravitational Oases

Diagram of the five Lagrange points

Lagrange Points: The Hidden Instability

The Lagrange points are five positions in space where gravitational forces and the centrifugal effect balance each other out. Mathematically discovered by Joseph-Louis Lagrange (1736-1813), they emerge from the study of the restricted three-body problem. The equilibrium conditions are expressed by canceling the resultant acceleration \(\vec{a} = \vec{g}_1 + \vec{g}_2 + \vec{a}_{\text{centrifugal}}\).

The restricted three-body problem refers to a configuration where two massive bodies follow an orbit determined by their mutual gravitation, while a third body, of negligible mass, moves in their combined gravitational field without disturbing the dynamics of the first two. This approximation preserves the essential symmetries of the system and reveals the existence of five dynamic equilibrium zones, the Lagrange points, whose local stability can be analyzed in the rotating reference frame. It allows determining stable or unstable directions, libration frequencies, without having to address the general three-body problem, which is intrinsically chaotic and unsolvable.

Beyond the Myth: The Fragility of Lagrange's Gravitational Oases

The equilibrium points L1, L2, and L3

L1, L2, and L3 are equilibrium points only in appearance: they are actually quasi-unstable, so that the slightest perturbation (radiation pressure, gravitational variations) initiates a gradual drift.

In this unstable regime, a small deviation naturally grows until it expels the object from the equilibrium surface. The characteristic time for this amplification to reach a significant amplitude is short on the orbital scale: on the order of a few weeks to a few months, depending on the mass of the bodies involved and the nature of external perturbations.

The equilibrium points L4 and L5

The stability of L4 and L5 depends on the ratio between the two masses that create these equilibrium points. A number, denoted 𝜇, is defined to measure "how much" the smaller mass weighs relative to the total. If this ratio is less than a critical value (≈ 0.0385), then L4 and L5 become quasi-stable zones. For the Earth-Sun pair, this value (≈ 3 × 10-6) is much lower than the critical value. This explains why the L4 and L5 points of the Sun-Earth system are stable, capable of retaining objects such as Trojan asteroids.

However, an object placed near L4 or L5 does not remain motionless; it "oscillates" around the equilibrium point, somewhat like a marble spinning in a hollow. As long as these oscillations remain small, the object remains trapped in the region, describing a closed curve shaped like a "tadpole," a rounded loop around the equilibrium point "the head" and a "tail" that stretches along the main orbit.

The object leaves this zone only if its oscillations become too large: it then crosses a dynamic boundary called the "separatrix." This growth is very slow, as it occurs through a chaotic diffusion phenomenon: tiny perturbations, accumulating over tens of thousands of orbits, gradually increase the amplitude of the oscillations, leading to ejection.

Comparison of the Five Lagrange Points

Dynamic properties of Lagrange points and associated missions
PointType of equilibriumStability durationProbes or telescopes
L1Unstable equilibriumA few weeks to a few monthsSOHO (ESA/NASA, 1995): study of the Sun and solar wind
ACE (NASA, 1997): analysis of solar wind and energetic particles
DSCOVR (NOAA/NASA, 2015): space weather monitoring and solar wind
Wind (NASA, 1994): study of solar plasma and magnetosphere
Hinode (JAXA, 2006): high-resolution solar observation
Solar Orbiter (ESA/NASA, 2020): images of the Sun and polar solar wind
Parker Solar Probe (NASA, 2018): exploration of the solar corona
L2Unstable equilibriumA few weeks to a few monthsJames Webb Space Telescope (NASA/ESA/CSA, 2021): infrared and cosmology
Planck (ESA, 2009-2013): cosmic microwave background
Herschel (ESA, 2009-2013): infrared observation
Gaia (ESA, 2013-): 3D mapping of the Milky Way
WMAP (NASA, 2001-2010): anisotropies of the cosmic background
Euclid (ESA, planned 2024): dark energy and large-scale structure
SPICA (proposed): far-infrared mission
L3Unstable equilibriumA few weeks to a few monthsNo operational mission
L4Stable equilibriumThousands to millions of yearsObservation of Trojan asteroids (such as 624 Hektor)
Planned missions: Lucy (NASA, 2027): study of Jupiter's Trojan asteroids
L5Stable equilibriumThousands to millions of yearsEarth Trojan Survey project: detection of Earth Trojans
Future missions planned to study Trojans and orbital stability

Articles on the same theme

Lagrange Points: The Illusion of Stable Gravitational Oases Lagrange Points: The Illusion of Stable Gravitational Oases
Nemesis: The Theory of the Sun's Companion Star Nemesis: The Theory of the Sun's Companion Star
Solar System vs. Stellar Systems: A Comparison of Planetary Systems Solar System vs. Stellar Systems: A Comparison of Planetary Systems
The Faint Young Sun Paradox: Why Wasn't Early Earth Frozen? The Faint Young Sun Paradox: Why Wasn't Early Earth Frozen?
380 billion billion megawatts: The Solar Energy Excess 380 billion billion megawatts: The Solar Energy Excess
The Ecliptic or the Apparent Orbit of the Sun The Ecliptic or the Apparent Orbit of the Sun
Solar maximum and minimum Solar maximum and minimum
How to weigh the sun? How to weigh the sun?
The Sun: When the Yellow Star Turns Blue The Sun: When the Yellow Star Turns Blue
Explanation of the 8 of the analemma Explanation of the 8 of the analemma
Frost Line: The Boundary That Shaped the Planets Frost Line: The Boundary That Shaped the Planets
Tourist trip in the solar system Tourist trip in the solar system
Sunspots and the Solar Cycle: From Minimum to Maximum Sunspots and the Solar Cycle: From Minimum to Maximum
The infernal journey of the photon or random walk The infernal journey of the photon or random walk
Dynamics of Solar Cycles and Physical Mechanisms of Solar Flares Dynamics of Solar Cycles and Physical Mechanisms of Solar Flares
Baily grains in a solar eclipse Baily grains in a solar eclipse
Birth, Life and Death of the Sun: Chronicle of an Average Star Birth, Life and Death of the Sun: Chronicle of an Average Star
Grains of Baily or pearls of light Grains of Baily or pearls of light
Sunlight and wavelengths Sunlight and wavelengths
The chaotic formation of the solar system The chaotic formation of the solar system
Solar Storms and Catastrophic Scenarios Solar Storms and Catastrophic Scenarios
Solar Prominences: Filaments of Matter in the Solar Atmosphere Solar Prominences: Filaments of Matter in the Solar Atmosphere
Why Does the Sun Rotate So Slowly? The Mystery of the Missing Angular Momentum Why Does the Sun Rotate So Slowly? The Mystery of the Missing Angular Momentum
Venus Transit of June 5 and 6, 2012: Last Crossing Before a Century Venus Transit of June 5 and 6, 2012: Last Crossing Before a Century
Transit of the Moon in front of the Sun seen from space in 2007 Transit of the Moon in front of the Sun seen from space in 2007
Solar Winds: A Key Phenomenon of Interplanetary Space Solar Winds: A Key Phenomenon of Interplanetary Space
Heliosphere: At the Borders of the Solar System Heliosphere: At the Borders of the Solar System
Chaos and sensitivity to initial conditions Chaos and sensitivity to initial conditions
Stability and Chaos: Limits of the Solar System’s Orbital Harmony Stability and Chaos: Limits of the Solar System’s Orbital Harmony