Solar Storms and Catastrophic Scenarios

The Sun, Our Capricious Star: Solar Storms

Solar storms are explosive events related to the Sun's magnetic activity, including coronal mass ejections (CMEs) and intense solar winds. A super solar storm is characterized by exceptionally powerful particle flows and magnetic fields, capable of strongly interacting with Earth's magnetosphere and critical technological systems.

Conditions for a Super Solar Storm to Reach Earth

Not all solar ejections are directed toward Earth. For a super solar storm to become truly dangerous to our planet, several physical conditions must be met:

• Orientation of the coronal mass ejection (CME): The CME must be directed toward Earth. Solar ejections propagate through space along highly variable trajectories, and only those aligned with the Sun-Earth line can induce significant geomagnetic disturbances.
• Favorable magnetic polarity: The Bz component of the interplanetary magnetic field must be southward (negative component). Opposite polarity limits interaction with Earth's magnetosphere, reducing the intensity of induced currents and thus the ground impact.
• Speed and density of the ejection: The higher the speed of the ejected plasma and its density, the greater the energy transferred to the magnetosphere. Speeds of \(\sim2000\,\text{to}\,\text3000 km/s\) and particle densities above \(\sim 10^3 \, cm^{-3}\) can generate extreme geomagnetic storms.
• Concomitant solar activity: Super storms often occur during solar maxima (cycle of \(\sim 11\,\text{years}\)), when magnetic activity is high, favoring the formation of complex sunspots and multiple eruptions that can combine.
• Interaction with pre-existing solar wind: A strong pre-existing solar wind or a series of previous ejections can compress the magnetosphere and amplify the effect of a new CME. The geometry of the shock wave and the angle of incidence on Earth's field are then decisive.

The convergence of these factors makes super solar storms rare but potentially catastrophic, as it maximizes the transfer of energy from the Sun to Earth's and space systems.

Impacts on Earth and Infrastructure

A super solar storm can significantly affect our planet and its technological systems. The main impacts include:

• High-voltage electrical grids: Geomagnetically induced currents (GICs) can cause voltage surges in transformers and transmission lines, leading to localized or widespread blackouts. Studies estimate that GICs of the order of \(\sim 10^6\) A can be induced in the most sensitive networks.
• Satellites and spacecraft: Energetic particle fluxes and intense magnetic fields can damage electronic circuits, degrade solar panels, disorient navigation systems, and reduce the lifespan of satellites in low Earth and geostationary orbits.
• Communication systems: HF communications and long-distance transmissions can be severely disrupted by ionization of the ionosphere and radio signal scintillation. Fiber optic communication networks remain protected, but relay infrastructures and stations can be affected.
• Air and maritime transport: Aircraft using GPS for navigation, particularly on polar routes, may experience positioning errors. Exposure to solar radiation increases for crews and passengers at high altitudes.
• Critical computer systems: Data centers, hospitals, banks, and government infrastructures depend on stable power supply and surge protection. A super storm can cause service interruptions and loss of sensitive data.
• Scientific instruments and observatories: Radio astronomy receivers, space observatories, and particle detectors may experience electronic noise, false readings, or temporary physical degradation.

The combination of these effects shows that a super solar storm is not only an astrophysical event, but a real technological and economic risk for our connected civilization.

Frequency of Super Storms

The convergence of favorable conditions—CME orientation toward Earth, appropriate magnetic polarity, high speed and density, maximum solar activity, and interaction with pre-existing solar wind—makes super solar storms extremely rare.

Historical and isotopic analyses show that events comparable to the Carrington storm of 1859 occur on average every 100 to 200 years. Thus, the annual probability of a truly catastrophic super storm for our modern infrastructure is estimated between 0.01% and 0.1%, but the potential impacts on our modern infrastructure make the event catastrophic.

Probability and Forecasts of a Super Solar Storm

Comparative Table of Major Solar Storms