fr en es pt
Astronomy
Asteroids and Comets Black Holes Children Chemical Elements Constellations Earth Eclipses Environment Equations Evolution Exoplanets Galaxies Light Matter Moons Nebulas Planets and Dwarf Planets Probes and Telescopes Scientists Stars Sun Universe Volcanoes Zodiac New Articles Shorts Archives
Contact the author
RSS astronoo
Follow me on Bluesky
Follow me on Pinterest
English
Français
Español
Português
 


Last updated July 6, 2025

The Faint Young Sun Paradox: Why Wasn't Early Earth Frozen?

The Faint Young Sun Paradox

The Dim Light of the Primitive Sun: Evolution of Solar Luminosity

The Sun gradually increases its luminosity during its evolution on the main sequence due to the accumulation of helium in its core. This process is well-modeled in stellar astrophysics. Since its birth (about 4.6 billion years ago), the Sun's luminosity has increased by about 30%. It is estimated that at the time of the early Earth (4 billion years ago), the Sun emitted only ~70% of its current luminosity.

Time (since the formation of the Sun)Age of the SunLuminosity \(L / L_\odot\)
00 Ga0.70
1 Ga3.6 Ga~0.79
2 Ga2.6 Ga~0.88
3 Ga1.6 Ga~0.97
4.6 Ga (today)01.00
6 Ga+1.4 Ga~1.10
8 Ga+3.4 Ga~1.40 (end of main sequence)

The Faint Young Sun Paradox: A Climatic Enigma

The Faint Young Sun Paradox, first stated in 1972 by Carl Sagan (1934-1996), highlights an apparent inconsistency between astrophysical models and terrestrial geological data. This paradox raises a contradiction between the estimated solar energy in the past and the conditions necessary for the appearance of life on Earth. 4.6 billion years ago, the Sun emitted only ~70% of its current luminosity; such a reduction in sunlight should have plunged the early Earth into a global ice age, preventing the presence of liquid water on the surface.

However, geological data reveal the existence of non-frozen paleosols and aqueous sedimentary strata dating from this time. Microbial life, which requires liquid water, would have appeared very early in Earth's history, probably around 3.5 to 4.1 billion years ago, during the Archean eon.

A Sun 30% Weaker: What Mechanisms Kept Water Liquid?

Various mechanisms are considered to explain this compensatory warming:

These hypotheses likely combined, but their relative weight (unknown) must be adjusted to avoid antagonistic effects (e.g., solar wind vs. dense atmosphere). To date, the relative contribution of each mechanism to the warming of the early Earth is not precisely known, but climate models and geological data allow estimating orders of magnitude.

Scientific Estimates of CO₂ Concentration

Geological PeriodSolar Luminosity
\(L/L_\odot\)
Estimated CO₂ ConcentrationScientific References
-4.0 Ga0.70~100,000 ppm (0.1 bar)Kasting (1993)
-3.0 Ga0.75~30,000 ppm (0.03 bar)Haqq-Misra et al. (2008)
-2.5 Ga0.80~10,000 ppm (0.01 bar)Charnay et al. (2017)

Estimation of Atmospheric Conditions Necessary for a Temperate Climate under a Young Sun

Period (~Ga)Estimated CO₂ (mbar)Estimated CH₄ (mbar)Surface TemperatureModel / Source
3.8~100~210–20°CCharnay et al. 2013 (3D GCM)
Archean (general)10–100a fewTemperate > 0°CCharnay et al. 2020 (review)

Limitations of Current Climate Models

The complete resolution of the paradox involves coupled climate-atmosphere-ocean-biosphere models. Despite recent progress, no model can exactly reproduce all geological observations with purely realistic physical hypotheses. This suggests that the early Earth was in a state of climatic stability limit, very sensitive to feedback.

For example, methane produced by methanogenic archaea in an anoxic environment could have played a major role. CH₄ being a very effective greenhouse gas (global warming potential 25 times higher than that of CO₂), its sufficient concentration would have prevented glaciation, before being eliminated by oxygen during the Great Oxidation around -2.4 Ga.

A Precarious Balance on the Edge of Freezing

The Faint Young Sun Paradox illustrates a fundamental truth of planetary climatology: the thermal stability of a habitable planet depends on a complex network of positive and negative feedbacks. On Earth, this network has maintained a surface temperature compatible with life, despite variations in solar irradiance over billions of years.

This paradox remains at the heart of research on primitive climatology and also guides habitability models for exoplanets. It finally highlights how crucial the initial conditions and internal geophysical properties of a planet (tectonics, magnetism, volcanic activity) are for the preservation of a temperate climate.

Articles on the same theme

The Faint Young Sun Paradox: Why Wasn't Early Earth Frozen? The Faint Young Sun Paradox: Why Wasn't Early Earth Frozen?
380 billion billion megawatts: The Solar Energy Excess 380 billion billion megawatts: The Solar Energy Excess
The Ecliptic or the Apparent Orbit of the Sun The Ecliptic or the Apparent Orbit of the Sun
Solar maximum and minimum Solar maximum and minimum
How to weigh the sun? How to weigh the sun?
The spicules of the Blue Sun The spicules of the Blue Sun
Explanation of the 8 of the analemma Explanation of the 8 of the analemma
Superb annular eclipse of 2010 Superb annular eclipse of 2010
The ring of fire from March 2010 The ring of fire from March 2010
Simulator, the revolution of the planets around the Sun Simulator, the revolution of the planets around the Sun
The solar system ice line The solar system ice line
Tourist trip in the solar system Tourist trip in the solar system
Finally the return of sunspots in 2010 Finally the return of sunspots in 2010
Solar pillar, a link between sky and earth Solar pillar, a link between sky and earth
The infernal journey of the photon or random walk The infernal journey of the photon or random walk
The most violent solar flares The most violent solar flares
Baily grains in a solar eclipse Baily grains in a solar eclipse
The Sun is a yellow dwarf star The Sun is a yellow dwarf star
Grains of Baily or pearls of light Grains of Baily or pearls of light
Sunlight and wavelengths Sunlight and wavelengths
The chaotic formation of the solar system The chaotic formation of the solar system
The perfect solar storm The perfect solar storm
Coronal mass ejections Coronal mass ejections
The Sun's angular momentum paradox The Sun's angular momentum paradox
Venus Transit of June 5 and 6, 2012: Last Crossing Before a Century Venus Transit of June 5 and 6, 2012: Last Crossing Before a Century
Transit of the Moon in front of the Sun seen from space in 2007 Transit of the Moon in front of the Sun seen from space in 2007
Solar Winds: A Key Phenomenon of Interplanetary Space Solar Winds: A Key Phenomenon of Interplanetary Space
Heliosphere: At the Borders of the Solar System Heliosphere: At the Borders of the Solar System
Chaos and sensitivity to initial conditions Chaos and sensitivity to initial conditions

1997 © Astronoo.com − Astronomy, Astrophysics, Evolution and Ecology.
"The data available on this site may be used provided that the source is duly acknowledged."
Contact −  Legal mentions −  English Sitemap −  Full Sitemap −  How Google uses data